Jaar: | 1984 |
Muziek/Tekst: | Jimmy Somerville Larry Steinbachek Steve Bronski |
Producer: | Mike Thorne |
Persoonlijke hitparade: | Aan persoonlijke hitparade toevoegen |
Binnenkomst: | 29/09/1984 (Positie 16) | ||||||||||||
Laatste week notering: | 08/12/1984 (Positie 38) | ||||||||||||
Piekpositie: | 6 (4 Weken) | ||||||||||||
Chartrun: | |||||||||||||
Aantal weken: | 11 | ||||||||||||
Positie aller tijden: | 3951 (958 Punten) | ||||||||||||
In de landen: |
|
Tracks | |||||||||
09/1984 7" Single Forbidden Fruit BITE 2 [uk] | |||||||||
09/1984 7" Single London / Metronome 882 014-7 | |||||||||
Toon details | Alles beluisteren | ||||||||
1. | Why? | 3:55 | |||||||
2. | Cadillac Car | 3:54 | |||||||
09/1984 12" Maxi Forbidden Fruit BITEX 2 [uk] | |||||||||
09/1984 12" Maxi London / Metronome 882 014-1 U | |||||||||
Toon details | Alles beluisteren | ||||||||
1. | Why? (Extended Version) | 7:44 | |||||||
2. | Cadillac Car (Extended Version) | 7:28 | |||||||
09/1984 12" Maxi Forbidden Fruit BITER 2 [uk] | |||||||||
Toon details | Alles beluisteren | ||||||||
1. | Why? (Remix) | 5:13 | |||||||
2. | Smaltown Boy (Extended Version) | 9:00 | |||||||
3. | Cadillac Car | 3:54 | |||||||
Versie | Lengte | Titel | Label Nummer | Formaat Medium | Datum |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
3:55 | Why? | Forbidden Fruit BITE 2 | Single 7" Single | 09/1984 | |
Extended Version | 7:44 | Why? | Forbidden Fruit BITEX 2 | Single 12" Maxi | 09/1984 |
Remix | 5:13 | Why? | Forbidden Fruit BITER 2 | Single 12" Maxi | 09/1984 |
4:02 | The Age Of Consent | Forbidden Fruit BITLP 1 | Album LP | 15/10/1984 | |
3:57 | Now That's What I Call Music! 4 | Virgin NOW4 | Compilatie LP | 26/11/1984 | |
3:57 | Now That's What I Call Music! 4 | Virgin CDP 26 0408 2 | Compilatie CD | 26/11/1984 | |
4:02 | The Age Of Consent [Bonus Tracks Edition] | Metronome / Phonogram 820 171-2 | Album CD | 21/12/1984 | |
Full 12" Version | 7:44 | The Age Of Consent [Bonus Tracks Edition] | Metronome / Phonogram 820 171-2 | Album CD | 21/12/1984 |
3:55 | High Life - 20 ungekürzte Original Top-Hits! | Polystar 819 202-1 | Compilatie LP | 1984 | |
Supersanremo 1985 | EMI 260508 1 | Compilatie LP | 11/02/1985 | ||
Remix | 6:17 | Hundreds & Thousands | London / Metronome 820 291-2 | Album CD | 09/1985 |
Remix | 6:17 | Hundreds & Thousands | Forbidden Fruit BITLP 2 | Album LP | 09/1985 |
3:55 | Formula 30 | Polystar 819 268-1 | Compilatie LP | 1985 | |
3:55 | The Sound Of Today | Arcade ADEH 182 | Compilatie LP | 1985 | |
Remix | 8:13 | To Love Somebody | London LONCD281 / 869 225-2 | Single CD-Maxi | 22/10/1990 |
3:57 | The Singles Collection 1984/1990 | London 828 268-2 | Album CD | 12/11/1990 | |
3:57 | The Singles Collection 1984/1990 | London 828 268-1 | Album LP | 12/11/1990 | |
3:56 | Party Power Pack - Vol. 2 | Polystar 516 640-2 | Compilatie CD | 1993 | |
4:02 | The Best Of 1980-1990 Vol. 10 | EMI 8312262 | Compilatie CD | 1994 | |
1995 Remix Version | 6:19 | Rainbow Nation | ZYX 3616-2 | Album CD | 13/02/1995 |
3:58 | Just Can't Get Enough: New Wave Hits Of The 80's Vol. 15 | Rhino R2 71978 | Compilatie CD | 20/06/1995 | |
Maxi | 7:46 | Tainted Love [Made In England (Les années New Wave)] | MCA MCT 32041 | Single 12" Maxi | 1995 |
4:03 | The Age Of Consent [Remastered] | London 828824-2 | Album CD | 11/11/1996 | |
3:58 | The Very Best Of [Collector's Edition] | WSM / London 0927 48440-2 | Album CD | 27/09/2002 | |
12" Version | 7:48 | The Very Best Of [Collector's Edition] | WSM / London 0927 48440-2 | Album CD | 27/09/2002 |
7:45 | I Love Disco 80s Vol. 3 | Blanco Y Negro MXCD-1703 | Compilatie CD | 21/05/2007 | |
12' Version | 7:43 | 80s Maxi - Best Of 12 Inches | Sony BMG 334 88 2 | Compilatie CD | 29/08/2008 |
4:05 | 100 Hits - 80s Pop | Demon DMG 100 019 | Compilatie CD | 06/10/2008 | |
4:05 | For A Friend - The Best Of | Music Club Deluxe MCDLX 100 | Album CD | 08/06/2009 | |
12" Version | 7:47 | Pearls Of The 80s - Maxis Vol. 2 | DA DCD 872483-2 | Compilatie CD | 23/04/2010 |
4:02 | 100 Hits - Electric Eighties | Demon DMG 100 065 | Compilatie CD | 04/10/2010 | |
4:04 | Die ultimative Chart Show - Die erfolgreichsten Synthie Pop Hits aller Zeiten | Polystar 06007 5332839 | Compilatie CD | 04/03/2011 | |
4:05 | The Age Of Consent [Deluxe Edition] | Edsel / Demon EDSK 7008 | Album CD | 02/07/2012 | |
Remix | 5:10 | The Age Of Consent [Deluxe Edition] | Edsel / Demon EDSK 7008 | Album CD | 02/07/2012 |
Goldberg Remix | 6:18 | The Age Of Consent [Deluxe Edition] | Edsel / Demon EDSK 7008 | Album CD | 02/07/2012 |
4:03 | Joe FM Hitarchief Top 2000 Volume 4 | ARS 8824165 | Compilatie CD | 21/09/2012 | |
4:04 | Veronica Album Top 1000 Allertijden - Editie 2013 | Sony 88883703452 | Compilatie CD | 22/04/2013 | |
4:03 | 80s Dancefloor - The Collection | Rhino 2564630535 | Compilatie CD | 07/11/2014 | |
12" Version | 7:48 | Dance & Desire: Rarities & Videos | Edsel / Rhino / Demon EDSG8044 | Album CD | 17/11/2014 |
3:56 | Joe FM - 80's Top 800 volume 3 | Universal 536.117-4 | Compilatie CD | 18/05/2015 | |
3:57 | Now Yearbook '80-'84 - The Final Chapter | Now CDYBNOW8084 | Compilatie CD | 02/12/2022 | |
12" Version | 7:48 | Disco Discharge Presents Box Of Sin - Full-Length Gay Clubbing 1980-1989 | Edsel EDSL0155 | Compilatie CD | 29/09/2023 |
»» alles tonen |
Singles - Dutch Charts | Titel | Binnenkomst | Piek | Weken |
---|---|---|---|
Smalltown Boy | 21/07/1984 | 1 | 13 |
Why? | 29/09/1984 | 6 | 11 |
It Ain't Necessarily So | 15/12/1984 | 21 | 7 |
I Feel Love (Bronski Beat / Marc Almond) | 27/04/1985 | 11 | 6 |
Hit That Perfect Beat | 14/12/1985 | 19 | 6 |
Smalltown Boy (1991 Remix) (Jimmy Somerville with Bronski Beat) | 16/03/1991 | 72 | 4 |
Albums - Dutch Charts | Titel | Binnenkomst | Piek | Weken |
The Age Of Consent | 20/10/1984 | 4 | 33 |
The Singles Collection 1984/1990 (Jimmy Somerville, Bronski Beat And The Communards) | 22/12/1990 | 6 | 27 |
Schöne und Güten Platte von Jimmy & Bronski Beat aus 1984 !!! Leider nie auf einer # 1 Hit in Holland !!! | |
Tell me whyyy! Giller van Bronski Beat. | |
Dutch Radio 2 Top 2000 notering in 2007 (1925) | |
Lekkere discoplaat!!!!! Deze plaat en videoclip vond ik meteen leuk, omdat ie hier tenminste niet in elkaar werd geslagen (zie mijn review bij "Smalltown boy") | |
nog aardig | |
Laatst gewijzigd: 23/04/2018 13:34 | |
5 stars | |
Goed nummer. | |
Bronski Beat kan toch weinig fout doen bij me. Maar dit is een van hun toppers. | |
Was iin 1981 de opvolger van hun nummer één-hit 'Smalltown Boy'. Ook 'Why' werd destijds in de officiële Vlaamse charts een top-10-hit, maar de hoogste plaats bereikten ze ditmaal niet. Toch een vier sterren-nummer voor mij. | |
kan er mee door | |
Hoor het graag af en toe | |
Nummer dat memorabel en herkenbaar is en voor mijn smaak ook wel iets de betere t.o.v. Smalltown boy. Score van goed-gemiddeld kan evenwel toch volstaan. | |
Very good! | |
#10 peak in Australia, 1984; #6 peak UK. ⌜ᴰᴬ⌝ Ꮲk.⌠#29⌡ | |
Ok pop plaat door het Britse trio. |